|

|
Jade, a shade of pain,
and then you die.
Seal, Deep Water
The history of Burma's jade mines
in the West is a brief one. While hundreds of different reports, articles
and even books exist on the famous ruby deposits of Mogok, only a
handful of westerners have ever made the journey to northern Burma's
remote jade mines and wrote down their findings. Occidental accounts
of the mines make their first appearance in 1837. Although in 1836,
Captain Hannay obtained specimens of jadeite at Mogaung during his
visit to the Assam frontier (Hannay, 1837), Dr. W.Griffiths (1847)
was the first European to actually visit the mines, in 1837 (Griffiths,
1847). The following is his account, as given in Scott and Hardiman
(1900-1901):
These celebrated serpentine mines occupy a valley of somewhat
circular form, and bounded on all sides by thickly wooded hills
of no great height. To the north the valley passes off into a ravine,
down which a small streamlet that drains the valley escapes, and
along this at a distance of two or three miles another spot of ground
affording serpentine is said to occur. The valley is small; its
greatest diameter, which is from east to west, being about three
quarters of a mile, and its smallest breadth from four hundred and
sixty to six hundred or seven hundred yards.
The whole of the valley, which appears formerly to have been occupied
by rounded hillocks, presents a confused appearance, being dug up
in every direction, and in the most indiscriminate way, no steps
being taken to remove the earth, &c., that have been thrown up in
various places during the excavations. Nothing in fact like a pit
or shaft exists, nor is there anything to repay one for the tediousness
of the march from Kamaing. The stone is found in the form of more
or less rounded boulders mixed with other boulders of various rocks
and sizes imbedded in a brick-coloured yellow, or nearly orange-coloured
clay, which forms the soil of the valley, and which is of considerable
depth. The excavations vary much in form, some resembling trenches;
none exceed twenty feet in depth. The workmen have no mark by which
to distinguish at sight the serpentine from the other boulders;
to effect this fracture is resorted to, and this they accomplish,
I believe, by means of fire. I did not see the manner in which they
work or the tools they employ, all the Shans having left for Kamaing,
as the season had already been over for some days. No good specimens
were procurable.
W. Griffiths, 1847
Journals of Travels in Assam, Burma,
Bootan, Afghanistan, and the Neighbouring Countries.
In 1888, two years after their annexation of Upper Burma, the
British dispatched a military expedition to the jade mines. Accompanying
the troops was an Englishman, W.Warry, whose account of the history
and working of the mines is one of the best. According to Charles
Crosthwaite (1912), Chief Commissioner of Burma for 1887-1890, Warry
was the expedition's advisor on Chinese affairs:
He belonged to the Chinese Consular Service, spoke Chinese well,
and understood that difficult people as well as an Englishman can.
He was on most friendly terms with the Chinese in Burma, and could
trust himself to them without fear.
Crosthwaite, 1912, The Pacification of Burma
Warry's description of the mines was given in the Myitkyina District
Gazetteer (Hertz, 1912) and is reproduced here in its entirety:
The jadestone or nephrite, has been known in China from a period
of high antiquity. It was found originally in Khoten and other parts
of Central Asia, and being of a brilliant white colour and very
costly, it was held in high esteem as symbolical of purity in private
and official life. The green variety of the stone seems to have
been extremely rare, but not entirely unknown, for attempts are
recorded to produce its colour artificially by burying white jade
in juxtaposition with copper. The discovery that green jade of fine
quality occurred in Northern Burma was made accidentally by a small
Yunnanese trader in the thirteenth century. The story runs that
on returning from a journey across the frontier he picked up a piece
of stone to balance the load on his mule. The stone proved to be
jade of great value and a large party went back to procure more
of it. In this errand they were unsuccessful, nobody being able
to inform them where the stone occurred. Another attempt, equally
fruitless, was made by the Yunnan Government in the fourteenth century
to discover the stone; all the members of the expedition, it is
said, perished by malaria, or at the hands of hostile hill-tribes.
From this time onwards, for several centuries, no further exploration
in the jade country seems to have been undertaken by the Chinese.
Small pieces of the stone occasionally found their way across the
frontier, but the exact source of the supply continued unknown.
The year 1784 marks the final termination of a protracted series
of hostilities between Burma and China, and from this time dates
the opening of a regular trade between the two countries. Adventurous
bands of Chinese before long discovered that the jade-producing
districts lay on the right bank of the Uru river, and a small but
regular supply of the stone was now conveyed every year to Yunnan.
Impracticable roads, a malarious climate, and an unsettled country
prevented the expansion of the trade. Some twenty or thirty Chinese
at the most went up into the jade country each season and a very
small proportion of these ever returned. In the Chinese temple at
Amarapura is a long list containing the names of upwards of 6,000
Chinese traders deceased in Burma since the beginning of the present
century to whom funeral rites are yearly paid. The large majority
of these men are known to have lost their lives in the search for
jade. The roll includes only the names of well-known and substantial
traders. Could the number of smaller traders and adventurers who
perished in the same enterprise be ascertained, the list would be
swelled to many times its present size.
The earliest route followed by the jade traders led from Momein
to Kunyung Lien and Chansi on the Yunnan frontier. Here the Kachin
Hills were entered and a week's journey over exceedingly difficult
mountain-tracks brought the travellers to Kachins-Yimma on the Irrawaddy,
a place which appears to be some distance above Talawgyi. The river
being crossed here, the parties made their way as best they could
towards Hsimu (Seikmo) [Sate Mu] in the valley of the Uru river,
which they usually reached after a toilsome march of some ten days.
The Hsimu quarries were first discovered in 1790; they yielded a
very brilliant jade, pieces of which are said to have been sometimes
exchanged at Momein for their weight in silver.
In 1798 the Chinese traders at Ava, with the assistance of the
Burmese Government, opened up a new route to the mines, namely from
Ava to Menrua (Monywa), thence up the Chindwin and Uru rivers to
Serua (Seywa), from which place the mines then worked were distant
some two days' journey by land. The trade in jade now developed
rapidly, and Serua, being the depot, rose into considerable importance.
After some years, however, this route became insecure owing to the
hostility of certain Kachin tribes who commenced to waylay and rob
caravans; and the original Kutung (Kuyung) route being for similar
reasons unavailable, another new overland road was adopted, namely
from Katha via Mawlu, Mohnyin
and Loastun (Lawsun) to Endaw (Indaw); thence three days to the
mines.
The direct road into China via Bhamo had been known for centuries,
but fear of the Kachins appears to have deterred traders from making
a regular use of it. Even cotton from Lower Burma was constantly
sent up by river past Bhamo to Tsenbo (Sinbo) or to Talaw, and was
conveyed thence by mules into Yunnan. In 1805 the first consignments
of jade were sent down the Mogaung river to Tsenbo (Sinbo), where
they were given into the charge of the cotton caravans; and from
1807 for some years a favourite route for jade was from the mines
by way of Myuhung (old Mogaung), Tapaw, and Hokat to Talaw on the
Irrawaddy, whence the stone travelled overland with the cotton caravans
via Sima, Tachai (the frontier between Burma and outlying tribes
dependent on China) and Sanda (Santa) (the frontier of China proper)
to Momein (Tengyueh). This route is still used to a small extent.
It is under the protection of a powerful Chinese family at Tachai
called Chao, to whom travellers pay a fixed sum for safe conduct.
Early in the present century the Burmese Kings seem to have become
aware of the importance of the jade trade and of the revenue which
it might be made to yield them. In 1806 a Burmese Collectorate was
established at the site of what is now the town of Mogaung, and
a guard of some thirty Burmese troops under a Military Officer was
regularly stationed at the mines during the working season to protect
the trade and to maintain order. This force was always accompanied
by the Amatgyi, or hereditary
noble, of the Mogaung district, whose special duty was to control
the hill-tribes. The principal Kachin Sawbwas
[princes] were also in the habit of meeting the Burmese official
in Mogaung and escorting him up to the mines, where they provided
him with entertainment during his stay.
Mogaung now became the headquarters of the jade trade in Burma.
Comparatively few Chinese actually went up to the mines; the Kachins
themselves brought down most of the stone to Shuitunchun, a sandbank
opposite Mogaung, where a large bazaar was held during the season.
The Burmese Collector imposed no tax upon the stone until it was
ready to leave Mogaung, when he levied an ad
valorem duty of 33 per cent, and issued a permit which was
examined by his deputy at Tapaw, one day's journey from Mogaung
by river. After this the stone passed freely anywhere in Burma without
further charge or inspection. The value of jade was determined for
purposes of taxation by an official appraiser. This officer, however,
by private arrangement with the traders and the Collector, estimated
all stone about one-third of its real value. The actual duty paid
was therefore small and business proceeded smoothly, cases of friction
between the traders and the customs officers being of very rare
occurrence. All payments were made in bar silver. The metal used
was at first fairly pure, but it was soon debased by a large admixture
of lead. Rupees did not come into general use until 1874.
Besides the duty leviable at Mogaung, the stone had to bear certain
charges, authorized and unauthorized, at the mines and Namiakyaukseik
(Nanyaseik), one day's journey from the mines:-(1) The Burmese officer
at the mines imposed a monthly tax of 1 tael (about 4 annas) on
everybody who came to trade; from this charge Burmans and actual
workers in the mines were exempt; (2) a further sum of 2.5 taels
(about 10 annas) was charged for a pass which was issued for each
load of jade leaving the mines for Namiakyaukseik; (3) at Namiakyaukseik
4 taels (about a rupee) was paid on the arrival of every load to
an agent of the Mogaung Collector permanently stationed there. Of
these charges the Chinese regarded the first and third as legitimate,
and the second as an unauthorized gratuity to the subordinates of
the Mines Officer. All the above charges seem to have varied slightly
from year to year.
The Kachins levied no toll on stones at the mines or proceeding
down to Mogaung. Their rights appear to have been well understood
and respected. They were regarded as the absolute owners of all
the stone produced in their country. This ownership was never directly
called in question by the King of Burma. As I shall point out below,
the furthest length he went in this direction was to exclude all
competition during the years when he bought jade from the Kachins.
The Kachins on their side acknowledged the sovereignty of the King
of Burma by admitting his officers to mines; by allowing them to
purchase a certain quantity of stone for the Kings' use at a nominal
price; and by acquiescing in certain charges imposed by those officers
and in certain interferences at the mines, whereby the price of
their stone was injuriously affected. I shall advert below to the
rights of Kachin Sawbwas over
their own people engaged in the jade-mining.
Under the system just described, the jade trade continued to flourish
for many years. The period of its greatest prosperity is comprised
within the years 1831-40, during which time at least 800 Chinese
and 600 Shans were annually engaged in business or labour at the
mines. All the stone was sent by one of the abovementioned routes
to Yunnanfu, at this time the great emporium of the trade. The business
there was mainly in the hands of Cantonese merchants, who bought
the rough stone in large quantities and carried it back to be cut
and polished at Canton.
In 1841 war broke out between Great Britain and China. Hostilities
first commenced at Canton and the effect on the jade trade was not
long in making itself felt. Cantonese merchants no longer came to
buy stone at Yunnanfu. Stocks accumulated and Yunnan traders ceased
to go up to the mines. The Kachins, suffering from this stoppage
of business, made urgent representations to the Burmese at Mogaung;
and in 1842 a Burmese Officer proceeded from Mogaung to Momein to
enquire if any offence had been given to Chinese traders that they
did not come as usual to the mines. There was a partial revival
of the trade for a few years commencing with 1847, but the disturbed
state of Southern China, consequent upon the Taiping rebellion of
1850 prevented a complete recovery; and with the outbreak of the
Panthay rebellion in 1857 the roads leading to Yunnanfu were blocked
and all business in jade came to a standstill for several years.
During the early part of the period just passed in review the
Chinese estimate that the average amount of duty collected each
year did not exceed Rs. 6,000, the output of jade being small and
the official appraisers venal. About the year 1836, when the trade
was most flourishing, Rs. 21,000 was the probable amount of the
annual collections. After 1840, the duty fell to Rs.3,000 or less,
and then it dwindled away to nothing. The above estimates are probably
below the mark, as the Chinese would for obvious reasons, be inclined
to understate the real amount.
The year 1861 witnessed a great improvement in the jade trade.
From that date until now, the bulk of the stone has been carried
by sea to Canton. In 1861 the first Cantonese merchants [merchant]
arrived in Mandalay. He bought up all the old stocks of jade and
conveyed them to China by sea, realising a large fortune on this
single venture. His example was quickly followed by other Cantonese,
and once more the trade in jade revived and numerous Yunnanese went
up to the mines. The principal quarries were now at Sanka, a place
recently visited by the Mogaung column. Stone had been discovered
there many years before, but had been pronounced poor in quality
and scarcely worth the troubles of working. Now, however, upon a
second trial, it proved to be equal or superior to that from the
earlier mines, the colour having, as the Kachins alleged, matured
and deepened in the interval. The yearly duty collected at this
time probably amounted to at least Rs.27,000.
Hitherto the collection of the duty had been in the hands of an
official who had paid a very high price at Ava for his appointment
and who was in the habit of remitting to the capital only as much
as he thought fit-usually about one-fifth of the actual receipt.
In 1866 the tax was farmed out for the first time. The price obtained
was Rs.60,000 for a three-years' lease. At the expiration of this
term the King, dissatisfied with the amount of the jade revenue,
determined to buy all the stone from the Kachins himself, and he
appointed a high official to act as his agent at the mines. For
a whole season Chinese and other dealers in jade were excluded from
the mines; as the stone was dug up, it was purchased by the King's
agent, carried to Mogaung and there retailed to the traders. This
arrangement was of course highly unsatisfactory to the Kachins,
who first protested against the exclusion of other purchasers and
then, finding their protest of no avail, resorted to the much more
effectual method of curtailing the supply of stone and producing
only pieces of indifferent quality. For this reason the King's experiment
was a failure and the total revenue he secured did not equal the
proceeds derived from the sale of the monopoly in the preceding
year. The Chinese explain the failure on other grounds. The experiment,
they say, was doomed from the outset owing to the inherent impropriety
of a sovereign descending into the arena of trade and taking the
bread out of the mouths of his own subjects.
During the years 1870, 1871 and 1872, the King obtained an annual
remittance of Rs.12,000 from the Collector at Mogaung on account
of the jade duty. In the following year new deposits of fine jade
were discovered at Mantiemho, and the King again determined to become
the sole purchaser from the Kachins. On this occasion, too, the
revenue he realized fell far below the average of former years.
In 1874 the old system was reverted to and the collection amounted
to Rs.60,000. Once more in 1875, the King undertook to buy the stone
himself from the Kachins and again the experiment failed, though
not so badly as on the two previous attempts. About this time the
Iku quarry was discovered and, the output being very good, the right
of collecting the duty was sold in 1876 for three years for the
sum of Rs.60,000. In 1880, Wu Chi, the son of a Canton Chinaman
by a Burmese mother, obtained a three years' lease of the monopoly
at the rate of Rs.50,000 a year. In the second year of his term
Tomo (Tawmaw) quarries were opened and he made an immense fortune.
In the autumn of 1883, Mogaung was sacked by the Kachins, and
during the ensuing winter and spring there was no trade in jade.
In June 1884, order having been partially restored, a Chinese syndicate
represented by Li Te Su took the monopoly for three years agreeing
to pay Rs.10,000 the first year, Rs.15,000 the second, and Rs.20,000
the third.
The up-country was still unsettled and the lessees, by arrangement
with the traders, were permitted to collect duty at Bhamo instead
of, as herebefore, at Mogaung. During the first two years of their
term, owing to the disturbances connected with the adventurer Hsiao
Chin (Hawsaing) and the British occupation of Upper Burma they collected
little or no duty; but the proceeds of the third year left them
with a margin of Rs.20,000 over and above their total expenses for
the three years.
The tax was then farmed out by the British Government to Loenpin,
the present lessee. Matters between him and the jade merchants did
not proceed smoothly. Loenpin from the first was very strict in
exacting his rights. He taxed every piece of jade at Bhamo and Mandalay
that did not bear plain marks of the stamp of his predecessor, and
he declined, contrary to the practice of all his predecessors, to
make allowance in cases where the stamp had been obliterated through
frequent washing of the stone or by long storage underground. He
also refused to admit free of duty certain small re-imports of stone
from Momein about which previous lessees had made no difficulty.
So far Loenpin was acting within strict legal rights. His action
in other respects was more questionable. No duty had ever been collected
at Mogaung until the stone was reported ready to leave the place,
when duty was paid and a pass issued. Stone might thus remain at
Mogaung for years and change hands many times without being subjected
to any charge. Loenpin, however, insisted that all jade should pay
duty to him within five days from its arrival at Mogaung. This new
regulation bore very hardly upon the small traders in jade. For
example, such a man might have been lucky enough to secure a stone
worth a thousand rupees. On his arrival at Mogaung Loenpin would
say to him: 'I value your stone at five hundred rupees; pay me the
duty (Rs.166) within five days.' In many cases the owner would not
be able to raise this sum at so short a notice; and if he failed
to do so, Loenpin claimed to buy the stone at his own valuation,
that is to say, for just what it was really worth.
In addition to rendering himself obnosious [obnoxious] to all
traders in jade Loenpin had roused the apprehension of the Kachin
owners of the mines. He had made no secret from the first of his
intention, not merely to collect the duty, but to get the actual
management of the mines into his own hands. When the Chinese and
Kachins, by way of reprisals, stopped the supply of jade for some
weeks, he openly announced that this did not matter, for the English
were shortly coming to put him into armed possession of the mines
which he then intended to work with imported labour from Singapore.
The unpopularity which Loenpin had earned among all classes interested
in the jade trade culminated last December in the cowardly outrage
made upon him at Mogaung, which resulted in his death. The jade-producing
country may be roughly described as the large district lying between
the 25th and 26th parallels of latitude, and enclosed east and west
by the Uru and Chindwin rivers respectively. Small quantities of
jade have at one time or another been discovered over nearly the
whole of this tract, but the stone occurs in greatest abundance
at places near to the right bank of the Uru and considerable quantities
have been found in the bed of that stream. The names of the quarries
most celebrated in times past for the excellence of their output
are Hsimu [Sate Mu], Masa, Mopang and Tamukan [near Haungpa]. All
these places appear to be within the boundaries given above and
to lie at no great distance from one another. They have all ceased
to yield jade except in minute quantities, and they are now termed
the 'old mines,' Sanka being the latest name added to this list.
Jade also occurs at few isolated points outside the area just
described. At Mawhooh, one days' march on the road from Mohnyin
to Katha, the Chinese have recently reopened an old quarry the output
of which in former years was very rich. And the most celebrated,
perhaps, of all jade deposits appears to lie at a distance of several
days' journey from the principal mining districts. The place is
called by the Chinese 'Nantelung,' meaning the 'difficult of access,'
or 'the unapproachable place.' It is described as [a] large cliff
overhanging the Chindwin, the country being passed through being
very malarious and infested with wild animals and savage tribes.
The stone can only be obtained by swarming up the face of the cliff
with the aids of ropes and dislodging small portions with a hammer.
The water underneath is deep and the stone is thrown down into the
boats specially strengthened by a double platform of bamboo erected
across the deck. Many pieces are lost in the river and cannot be
recovered except by expert divers. As no Chinese have ventured to
go up to Nantelung for at least twenty years, the foregoing particulars
may be exaggerated or incorrected in some respects, but there seems
to be no doubt of the existence in that region of a deposit of jade
possessing remarkable brilliance and value. I have myself at Peking
seen specimens of jade said to come from Nantelung and I have heard
descriptions of the place very similar to that just given.
Sanka was the first point in the jade country visited by the Mogaung
column. It was reached after a march of some seventy miles from
Mogaung in a direction almost exactly north-west. Up to Sakaw, one-half
of the distance, the way led for the most part through dense jungle,
with a few pleasing breaks of comparatively open forest land. At
Sakaw the Endaw river was crossed, and the path onwards became hilly
and in some places exceedingly difficult on account of the narrowness
of the track and the steep gradients. The country traversed was
more open and some magnificent stretches of forest land were passed
through. Sanka is situated on the right bank of the Uru just opposite
its junction with the Nansant stream. Some twenty years ago Sanka
was celebrated for its output of fine jade, but the supply has long
been exhausted, and the place is now almost deserted. I spent the
greater part of a day in visiting the excavations of former years.
Thousands of pits had been dug along the sides of the low hills
and in the small intervening valleys. The diameter of the pits rarely
exceeded ten or twelve feet at the mouth, and the average depth
was about twelve feet. At two of these quarries work was still proceeding.
A few Kachins were engaged in lazily bailing out water and detaching
small pieces of stone which they brought up one after another to
the brow of the pit, and, after a moment's inspection, pronounced
to be worthless. In answer to my inquiry if they ever found a good
piece, they replied that this event happened sometimes once in three
months, sometimes once in six. The discovery of a good piece, however,
recompensed them for many months of labour. The pits they were working
belonged to a small Kachin Sawbwa, who gave them nothing but their
food unless they discovered jade, when they obtained a fair share
of the price realized. They told me that at many other old mines
a few men were still at work who thought themselves lucky if, in
the course of a year, they brought one or two pieces to light, and
they added that the bed of the Uru is still diligently searched
with much the same disproportionate results.
Sanka is the last of the 'old mines.' The 'new mines' have produced
immense quantities of stone, but none which approaches in quality
that yielded by the quarries of former years. It will be convenient
here to indicate briefly by points of difference between the old
stone and the new. The value of jade is determined mainly by the
colour, which should be a particular shade of dark green. The colour
however, is by no means everything; semi-transparency, brilliancy,
and hardness are also essential. Stone which satisfies these four
conditions is very rare. The last three qualities were possessed
to perfection by a large proportion of the old stone, but the dark-green
colour was rare and often absent altogether. The new stone, on the
other hand, possess abundant colour, but is defective in the other
three respects, being as a rule opaque, dull and brittle in composition.
These natural defects are aggravated by the injurious methods employed
in quarrying the new stone. A peculiarity which gave high value
to all stone found at the old mines was that [it] occurred in the
form of moderate size round lumps, having often the appearance of
water-worn boulders, and small enough to be detached and carried
away without undergoing any rough process of cleavages on the spot.
At the new mines the stone occurs in immense blocks which cannot
be quarried out by any tools possessed by the Kachins, but have
to be broken up by the application of heat, a process which, without
doubt, tends to make the stone more brittle and chalk-like.
These defects were not fully realized the first year that the
new mines were opened. The output of stone was large and the competition
keen. Hitherto only men of some capital had been able to engage
regularly in the trade. It had been impossible to do more than guess
at the value of any old stone, for each piece was complete in itself
and was usually protected by a thick outer capsule which effectually
concealed the colour within. All pieces therefore fetched a high
price, as any piece might on cutting prove to be of immense value.
But with the opening of the new mines, stone could not be bought
in fragments of any shape and size, and it was possible by the processes
of washing and holding in a strong light to determine with comparative
exactitude the amount and nature of the colour. The trade was thus
brought within the means of a large number of men who had not before
been in a position to take part in it. There was accordingly a rush
for the new mines in 1881, and the speculation in jade reached a
height not attained before. Large fortunes were made by those who
had the good luck to dispose of their stone before its defects were
discovered. In the second year there was a heavy fall in prices,
which involved the ruin of more than one of the largest jade merchants.
On 9th February [1888] the column marched from Sanka to Tomo (Tawmaw),
the largest of the new mines, all of which, namely, Pangmo, Iku,
Martiemmo and Mienmo, are situated in the near neighbourhood. The
road was broad, very steep in places, and after the first few miles
it continually ascended. It led for the most part through grand
forest scenery, the kanyin, the gangaw, and the cotton wood being
the prevailing trees. Here and there narrow belts of bamboo jungle
were passed through, but the undergrowth was as a rule scanty. At
the end of seven and a half miles from Sanka we emerged upon a broad
plateau, some hundreds of acres in extant, the whole of which had
been cleared for mining purposes. The excavations, which were in
some cases of considerable depth, presented the general appearance
of a series of limestone quarries at home. The largest quarry measured
about 50 yards in length by 40 broad and 20 deep. The bottom was
flooded to a depth of a few feet. It is the joint property of 120
Kachins in equal shares, one of which is held by Kansi Nawng, the
principal Sawbwa of the district.
No work was going on, and we saw no valuable pieces of jade, all
such having probably been hidden before our arrival; but round the
edge of the pits and along the paths were lying tons upon tons of
stone valuable in China, but not sufficiently valuable to repay
the cost of transport and the charges by the way. There was a mob
of several hundred people at Tomo [Tawmaw] when we arrived. Among
them I discovered only three Chinese, who expressed much surprise
at our having been allowed to come up; the rest were Shans and Kachins.
The Kachins of the jade country are described by the Chinese as
very different in disposition to the cognate tribes dwelling between
Bhamo and Yunnan. In outward appearance, however, the resemblance
was complete; and the language, Father Cadeaux informs me, is identical.
But, unlike their cousins of the Bhamo frontier, the Kachins at
the jade mines are naturally inclined to be peaceable and honest
in their dealings with strangers. They treat all traders with great
kindness and consideration; and although sums of money, amounting
to several lakhs [one lakh = 100,000], are often sent up from Mogaung
without a guard of any sort, robbery, or attempted robbery, is a
thing unknown. They have the reputation of being the most superstitious
of all the Kachin tribes. The remoteness of their country, the wildness
of the scenery, the peculiar nature of the climate, healthful to
them but deadly to strangers, the frequent earthquakes and violent
atmospheric disturbances, seem to have inspired in them a more devout
belief in the unseen powers and a readier disposition to consult
them on the most trivial subjects. In important matters, such as
the discovery or the opening of a jade mine, their action is entirely
determined by superstitious considerations. In their search for
stone they are guided by indications furnished by burning bamboos;
when it is discovered, favourable omens are anxiously awaited before
the discovery is announced to the Kachin community. A meeting is
then convened by the chief Sawbwa, and again sacrifice and other
methods of divination are resorted to in order to ascertain if the
mine should be worked at once or be allowed to remain undisturbed
for a period of years until the colour-such is the Kachin belief-is
sufficiently matured. If the indications are favourable to the immediate
opening of the mine, the land at and around the outcropping stone
is marked out by ropes into small plots a few feet square, which
are then apportioned among all the Kachins present. No Kachin belonging
to the same family is refused a share, no matter how far away he
may live.
The ground thus parcelled out, traders are invited to the mine,
and after an elaborate ceremonial is held at the opening of each
successive season. This year the sacrifices were on an unusually
large scale, an abundant output being desired in order to meet expected
orders on behalf of the Emperor of China, who is to be married shortly.
On the occasion of the Emperor Tungchih's marriage in 1872, it is
said that a sum amounting to four lakhs of rupees was expended at
Canton in buying jade for use at the ceremony, and a great impulse
was thereby given to the jade trade in Burma.
The Kachins have always claimed the exclusive right of digging
at the mines. They have, however, from time to time allowed Shans
to assist them, and in the early days Chinese were permitted to
work certain quarries temporarily abandoned by the Kachins. The
Chinese, however, found the labour severe and the results unsatisfactory,
and they have now for many years contented themselves with buying
stone brought to the surface by Kachins.
The season for jade operations begins in November and lasts until
May, when the unhealthiness of the climate [re: malaria] compels
all traders to leave and the flooding of the mines suspends further
operations on the part of the Kachins.
This flooding of the deepest and most productive quarries is the
greatest difficulty with which the Kachins have to contend, and
they have spent much labour and money in devising expedients, with
indifferent success, to meet it. There were at the time of our visit
elaborate bamboo structures over some of the largest quarries for
the purpose of bailing out the water. When the floor of the pit
can be kept dry a few hours-and this is as a rule only possible
in February and March-immense fires are lighted at the base of the
stone. A careful watch must then be kept, in a tremendous heat,
in order to detect the first signs of splitting. When these occur
the Kachins immediately attack the stone with pickaxes and hammers,
or detach portions by hauling on leavers inserted in the crack.
All this must be done when the stone is at its highest temperature,
and the Kachins protect themselves from the fierce heat by fastening
layers of plantain leaves round the exposed parts of their persons.
The labour is described as severe in the extreme and such as only
a Kachin would undertake for any consideration. The heat is insupportable,
even for onlookers at the top of the mine, and the mortality among
the actual workers is very considerable each season. The Chinese
take a malicious pleasure in reminding the Kachins that in the early
days when quarrying was easy the right of digging was jealously
withheld from outsiders; and they assure them that under present
conditions they need not be apprehensive of an infringement of their
monopoly.
The stone is purchased at the mines by Chinese traders. All payments
are made in rupees. An expert, or middleman, is nearly always employed
to settle the price. These middlemen, who are without exception
Burmese or Burmese-Shans, have from early times been indispensable
to the transaction of business at the mines; they charge the purchaser
five per cent on the purchase-money. The Kansi Sawbwa
occasionally takes a similar commission for settling prices between
the Kachins and Chinese; and he receives in addition very valuable
presents from traders desirous of conciliating his goodwill and
securing the first offer of stone he may be possessed of.
The jade having been purchased is carried by Shan and Kachin coolies
to Namiakyaukseik (Nanyaseik), one long day's journey from Tomo.
The cost of carriage is at present from Rs.5 to Rs.6 a load of 25
viss. Stones too large to be carried by one man pay at a much higher
rate, ten viss being reckoned as a load in such cases, and all the
men engaged being paid at this rate. From Namiakyaukseik the stone
proceeds by dug-outs down a small creek which flows into the Endaw
river some three miles below Sakaw, and thence the river is followed
to Mogaung. The transport of a load (25 viss) from Namiakyakseik
to Mogaung probably costs about half-a-rupee.
Besides the cost of carriage the stone has at present to pay certain
charges levied by Kachins at the mines and on the way down to Mogaung.
In Burmese times it was the custom of any Kachin, the output of
whose quarry was particularly good, to invite the chief Sawbwa
to come and select a piece for himself. Beyond this the Sawbwa
claimed no rights over the jade found in his country, except, of
course, over such as occurred on his own private property. Now,
however, since the withdrawal of the Burmese Mines Officer, the
Kansi Sawbwa has assumed and
enlarged some of the rights formerly exercised by that official.
At present he imposes a tax of Rs.2-8-0 on every load of jade that
leaves his country. This charge was levied three years ago, and
being an innovation it formed the subject of a protest from the
Chinese, on whose behalf the ex-Myook
of Mogaung wrote to the Kansi Sawbwa
asking him to remit it. The Sawbwa having read the letter cut it
to pieces with his dà [knife] to show the contempt in which he held
the remonstrance. The payment of this tax, however, is not rigidly
enforced; traders who can plead poverty, or who are intimate with
the Sawbwa or his agents, easily
obtain reduction or exemption.
At Namiakyaukseik the stone is subjected to a further charge of
Re.1 a load by the local Kachin Sawbwa,
who also imposes a tax of Re.1 on every boat coming up the creek;
and within the last few months a family of Kachins at Pentu (Puntu),
between Kamein (Kamaing) and Mogaung, have barricaded the river
at a narrow point where they take toll of passing boats.
Some jade is sent down the Uru and Chindwin rivers on rafts, and
the amount would be larger were it not for rapids which render the
navigation dangerous. At present little or no stone from the new
mines [Tawmaw] follows this route, which is used only for such jade
as can still be extracted from old mines in the lower valley of
the Uru.
Some jade, again, is carried direct to China, evading duty at
Mogaung. The proportion of the stone thus smuggled increased considerably
last year in consequence of the unfortunate relations between the
traders and the jade lessee. It probably amounted to one-fourth
of the total output; in ordinary years it is perhaps one-sixth.
But the export by this route can never be very large, because (1)
the demand for uncut stone in Yunnan is now comparatively small,
and (2) the direct overland transport from the mines to Momien costs,
in ordinary cases, more than the transport to Momien via
Bhamo plus the duty at Mogaung.
The present rate of overland carriage from Talawgyi to Momien is
Rs.40 for a load of 25 viss. The same amount of jade can be sent
from Bhamo to Momien for less than Rs.10. It is certain, however,
that some stone will always be smuggled in this way until there
is a customs station at the mines. Small pieces of jade possessing
high relative value will find this route convenient; and the several
hundred Shans who visit Tomo each season and return to China direct
will not be prevented from taking back with them as much as they
can conveniently carry.
The Tomo quarries have now been worked for seven years and the
stone is by no means exhausted, although the labour of extracting
it from the deeper pits is barely repaid by the price realized.
In the immediate neighbourhood of Tomo, the jade-supply is beginning
to fail. Last year, out of forty-four excavations only three yielded
good stone; and I now hear that during the last month thirty-seven
new pits have been dug, the jade from which has in every instance
proved valueless. This unsatisfactory result is attributed to the
recent visit of the foreign troops. But it is confidently asserted
that many new deposits of stone are known to the Kachins and will
be disclosed in due season. The supply has not failed for upwards
of a century, although no one particular mine has ever been profitably
worked for longer than a few consecutive years.
The demand for jade is universal throughout China, and the price
of the best stone shows no tendency to fall. Burma is practically
the only source of the supply, and there seems no reason to think
that the supply is likely to fall short of the demand. Considering
the large area over which the jadestone has at one time or another
been discovered, the impracticable nature of the country, covered
for the most part with thick jungle, and the rough character of
the prospecting, which consists merely in examining large and obvious
outcropping stones, it is probable that the jade hitherto discovered
bears a very small proportion to that still concealed. It is likely,
therefore, that in the jade country our Government possess a source
of revenue capable of considerable development. Putting out of sight
the probability of future discoveries of jade, there is no doubt
that the revenue derived from the present mines might be much improved
if free access could be obtained to the country. The introduction
of European appliances, which should supersede the present injurious
method of working the quarries, would add considerable value of
the output, a good part of which is now calcined by the action of
the heat. And the smuggling of stone overland to China would at
the same time be effectually prevented.
But a strong opposition from the Kachins must be expected to any
innovation proposed by our government. The wealth and influence
of the Kansi Sawbwa have greatly increased since the opening of
the Tomo [Tawmaw] quarries. Even before the British annexation of
Upper Burma he had begun to show some impatience at the yearly visits
of the Burmese Mines official to his country; and he had ceased
to escort that officer from Mogaung and to provide him with entertainment
during his stay in the hills. For the last six years he has been
entirely free from surveillance and control, and he has come, not
unnaturally, to regard himself as an independent chieftain. It is
improbable that he will admit a British garrison to his country
without an attempt at resistance. It is true that he made no objection
to the recent visit of the Mogaung column. But it was doubtful up
to the last moment whether he would take a friendly or a hostile
line, and it was well known that a number of the assembled Chiefs
were in favour of resisting the progress of the column. Probably
the assurance conveyed to the Sawbwa that no interference with his
rights was intended, and that the column would return immediately
after visiting the mines, had most weight in influencing his decision.
However this may be, I am convinced that any future attempt made
without the free previous consent of the Kachins to establish a
Military or Police post at the mines or to exercise any interference
with existing arrangements there, will need to be supported by the
presence of a considerable force.
W.Warry, 1888
From Hertz, 1912
Burma Gazetteer: Myitkyina District
Following Warry's account, Hertz goes on to describe the mines
and their methods of working, ca.1912:
There are the following mines:-
(1) Tawmaw.
(2) Ngobin.
(3) Mamon.
(4) Sabyi.
(5) Papyen.
(6) Sabwi.
(7) Pakhan.
These mines are now being worked. Kansi La has representatives
(Mawoks) at Tawmaw and Mamon; mines Nos. 4 to 7 are subordinate
to Mamon, all dues and collections being paid to the Mamon Mawok.
No. 2 is being worked in a desultory fashion and is said to be directly
under Kansi La. The Mamon mines are subdivided and called by different
names, such as Hintingyi, Hintingale, Maiche, etc., but, as they
are all very close to Mamon, they have been included under Mamon.
|
Tawmaw
This is the most important of the mines. It is worked exclusively
by Kachins. The claim-holders are also Kachins and are all relations
of Kansi La. There are over fifty claims being worked. The jade here
is found in large blocks. The pits are deep and the work arduous,
and only Kachins are equal to the task of baling out the mines and
quarrying the stone. This says much for the Kachin as a labourer.
These mines become flooded during the rains and the season's work
opens with the task of baling them out, which is done by a primitive
contrivence, no pumps being used. The method is as follows:-A long
horizontal pole, supported in the centre by two upright posts, is
weighted at one end with stones and to the other is fastened a long
cane rope with an empty kerosene tin or a bucket tied to the end of
it. A platform is built over the mouth of the pit, and on this the
balers sit and work the lifts by hauling on the cane rope. The water
is emptied from the buckets into wooden troughs and thus carried away.
The work of baling once started is carried on day and night, and considering
the means used the mines are cleared in quick time. After all the
water has been drawn off, the miners have to dig through thick layers
of hard rock, before they come upon the jade; this takes two and in
some cases three years of very hard work, but now that dynamite is
being used the work is got through more quickly.
Collections and
dues: Manhumanta or ad valorem dues.-This
is not paid in money. When jadestone is sold, a portion of it (awarded
by the elders of the mines) is given to Kansi La. It is impossible
to say what income he derives from this source, as the manhumanta
stone is taken charge of by the Mawok
(his agent) on behalf of Kansi La, and only sold when a favourable
price is offered. Since Kansi La's death in 1907, manhumanta has
been fixed at one-tenth ad valorem.
Export dues.-The
rates under this head are as follows:
On every mule-load of jadestone. 4 Rs.
8 A.
On every cooly-load of jadestone. 1 Rs. 8
A.
These are collected by the Mawok's men, who have kins
or pickets, on the roads leading out of Tawmaw.
Tolls.-Although
these not sanctioned by Government, yet they are imposed on food-stuffs
imported into the mines. The only regular cash rate is four annas
on a mule-load of rice. Importers of other articles, such as dried
fish, betel-nut, etc., pay in kind, giving some small present to
the men at the kins. These tolls
are used to remunerate the Mawok's hangers-on.
House-tax.-This
is collected from all residents in Tawmaw in the month of Tasaungmon.
The rate is Rs.5 a house for hill-tribesmen and Rs.10 a household
for those who are not members of a hill-tribe.
Gambling.-In
spite of Kansi La's attempts in the past to deny that he countenanced
gambling-dens, it is well known that they exist with his full permission.
"La Saing, Kansi La's nephew," Mr. Barnard writes, "has this year
leased out the right to keep an anzayon
(dice-gambling den) to Law Ta for Rs.2,000, while permission to
run a gamble known in Burmese as paukhnitse
has been given to Maung Ya for Rs.600. Gambling is suspended when
the Civil Officer visits Tawmaw, and instead of the evening gong
whose beat usually invited persons to try their luck with the dice,
and perhaps make their fortune, the village crier goes round and,
in a voice pitched high enough for the Civil Officer to hear, warns
the residents to close their shops early, take good care of their
property and refrain from wandering about after dark without a light."
Ngobin mines, Mamon village and mines
The Ngobin Mines are situated between Lonkin and Tawmaw. There are
only a couple of claims being worked.
At Mamon the Kachin is conspicuous by his absence. There is a
fairly large Shan-Burman village consisting of fifty-four houses,
which number increases considerably in the cold weather. Most of
the inhabitants are from the Upper Chindwin. Jade is found in these
mines in loose boulders at no great depth. Besides digging, the
stone is extracted from the Uyu [Uru] river (which flows near Mamon)
by diving. Some of the divers use diving-dresses, others go down
without, and it is surprising how long they remain under water.
Some of the diving-dresses are in such a deplorably bad state that
it would not be safe to use the best of them.
Myaungs.-These
are big drains dug over a likely piece of ground. They are connected
with a stream and the water coming down them carries away the earth,
thereby saving a lot of digging labour. They are worked mostly during
the rains.
Manhumanta.-All
stones valued at Rs.100 and over sold in the mines have to pay ten
per cent on the selling price to Kansi La. This charge is not met
by the seller. In all transactions there is a pwesa or broker, who
is paid five per cent ad valorem
by the purchaser. From what can be gathered Kansi La gets at least
Rs.1,500 a year under this head from Mamon.
Export dues.-The
rates are the same as in Tawmaw. A quantity of stone is also taken
down the Uyu river on rafts. The rafts are of three kinds, viz.:-
(1) Tatat paung (raft of a single thickness).
3 Rs.
(2) Hnitat paung (raft of double thickness. 6
Rs.
(3) Kadon paung
(made of a bundle of bamboos
capable of carrying a heavy load). 8 to 30 Rs.
The last kind of raft is not much used. A charge of eight annas
is made for each ticket issued in order to enable a load of jadestone
to be removed from the mines, which sum the writer takes as his
perquisite. The income from this source amounts to a very considerable
figure during the season.
Tolls.-No
tolls on imports are collected. Kansi La, it is said, attempted
to impose them, but the villagers threatened to leave, so he desisted.
Gambling.-
As at Tawmaw, gambling is carried on here on a large scale. The
Mawok, Maung Nyi, bought the
right to keep gambling-houses from Kansi La a few years ago for
Rs.1,800. The accounts were checked by Mr.Barnard, who found that
the Mawok made over Rs.4,000.
As he only takes one pice (G anna) on every rupee staked, the gaming
must be heavy. Kansi La's income from these mines must amount to
a considerable sum, for, according to information received, Kansi
La sold the mines for one season to UKha, of Mandalay, recently
for Rs.7,000. This included the right to collect fees on stones
and to keep gambling-dens.
The Sabyi Mines
The Sabyi Mines include those known as Salaungka and Kalamaw. They
are next in importance to Mamon, and both Kachins and Shan-Burmans
work them. The Mawok is subordinate
to the Mamon Mawok.
Manhumanta.-The
receipts under this head amount to over Rs.1,000 a year.
Export duties.-The
majority of the stones are taken to Mamon and assessed there.
The Papyen Mines
The Papyen mines are also subordinate to Mamon and include the following
minor mines:- (1) Nampongon.
(2) Manawa.
(3) Sabyiwa.
(4) Manachaung Pya.
The Mawok of
Papyen stated to Mr. Barnard that the manhumanta
collected by him amounted to a little more than Rs.100.
Export duties.-These duties are said to be included
in those of Mamon.
The Sabwi Mines
The Sabwi mines are subordinate to Mamon and include the Mawlakan
mine.
Manhumanta.-The
money collected is handed over to the Mamon Mawok and no separate
account is kept of it.
Tribute and Thathameda.-Tribute
is collected from Kachins in the Jade Mines Tract at the rate of
Rs.5 a house and from non-Kachins at the rate of Rs.10 per household.
Kansi La died early in 1907 and was succeeded by his nephew, La
Saing, the son of Kansi Nawng, the Lieutenant-Governor agreeing
to recognize La Saing provisionally as Duwa
on the understanding that his continuance as such depended
on his ability to keep order and on his observance of the instructions
given to him. La Saing died in 1908 and was succeeded by his son,
Sinwa Nawng.
The following are Excerpts from a report written in 1907 by Mr.
W.A. Hertz, Deputy Commissioner of Myitkyina, on the state of affairs
in the Jade Mines Tract at the time of Kansi La's death:-
"Kansi Nawng died a year after Captain Adamson's visit in 1888,
leaving a minor son named La Saing, and was succeeded by his younger
brother, Kansi La, the man who has recently died. Kansi La was given
a free hand in so far as the management of the mines went, and,
to a certain extent, also in the government of the tract, and, being
a man with a strong personality, he made himself very influential
in a short time. Whatever may be said against him, that he was illiterate,
conceited, and a savage, who was led by the nose by unprincipled
Burman and Shan hangers-on, it must be admitted that order was maintained
in the territory under his control. Crime was perhaps burked and
acts of injustice sometimes committed, but he usually made up for
the latter by giving the injured persons employment, or by putting
them in the way of making money. There were, consequently, no complaints
against him.
"The rights in
the mines of the Kansi family.-The evidence as to what rights
the Kansi family had in Burmese times is very conflicting. It is
certain, however, that they had rights of some sort, and that, if
the other headmen of the tract also had rights, they were gradually
deprived of them, until laterly Kansi La came to be regarded as
the owner of all the jadestone found at Tawmaw.
"Revenue derived from the Mines by Kansi La.-The
following dues and tolls were levied at the time of Kansi La's death:-
"The Tawmaw Mines.-
(i) One-third of all valuable jadestone extracted (Whether this
was called, or took the place of, manhumanta
is uncertain. La Saing says that it was Kansi La's share as owner
of the mines.)
(ii) Export tolls or kyaukhun-Rs.4-8-0
for every mule and Rs.1-8-0 for every man-load of jadestone.
(iii) Imports: tolls on food-stuffs and merchandise entering the
mines, at the rate of four annas per mule-load, and a small portion
of all articles carried my men, e.g., dried fish, etc.
(iv) Gambling fees, that is, fees for allowing gambling.
"Mamon and Subordinate
Mines.-
(i) Manhumanta-an ad valorem fee of 10per cent on all sale transactions
of jadestone valued at Rs.100 and over.
(ii) Export tolls or kyaukkun-
A mule-load of jadestone-Rs.4-8-0.
A coolie-load of jadestone-Rs.1-8-0.
A raft of single thickness (tatat paung) laden with
jadestone-Rs.6-0-0.
A raft of double thickness (hnitat paung) laden with
jadestone-Rs.6-0-0.
A kadon raft (made of bundles of bamboos) laden with
jadestone-Rs.8 to Rs.30 (according to the carrying capacity of the
raft).
(iii) Gambling fees, as at Tawmaw.
"The export tolls are tacitly recognized by Government although
the rates have not been fixed, but the import tolls are unauthorized.
"Until five or six years ago, the export tolls at Tawmaw and Mamon
were the same as those at the Hweka mines, namely, Re.1 per mule-load
of jadestone and eight annas per coolie-load, and no dues were levied
on imports. The rates were raised by Kansi La. Major Townsend's
estimate of the amount of kyaukkun
realized at Tawmaw in 1903 was Rs.1,090, but as the Shan Mawok
pays the Duwa a sum of Rs.1,000 yearly for the privilege of collecting
this revenue, the estimate must fall considerably short of the mark.
I have now gone carefully through the Mawok's
books for the current year, and have obtained the following figures,
which I believe represent fairly accurately the actual state of
affairs:-
|
| |
On Coolies |
On Mules |
| |
Rs. A.
P. |
Rs. A.
P. |
| |
|
26 0 0 |
| In Tabaung 1268 B.E. |
48 0 0 |
203 0 0 |
| In Tagu 1268 B.E. up to the middle of Kason 1263 |
448 0 0 |
|
| B.E. |
|
750 8 0 |
| |
448 0 0 |
750 8 0 |
| Estimate for the remaining half of Kason, when the |
|
|
| season will end. |
|
|
| Total... |
945 0 0 |
1,730 0 0 |
| Grang Total... |
Rs. 2,675-0-0 |
| I have not been able to obtain the figures
for last year as the books are incomplete. Ko Yin Det, the licensee
for the collection of royalty on jadestones, estimates the receipts
on account of kyaukkun in the Tawmaw mines at Rs.4,000 and, in support
of his estimate, produces a list that he has prepared from information
furnished by jadestone traders of the number of mule and coolie-loads
of jadestone that have left Tawmaw up to date. According to his list,
the number of mules laden with jadestone that have left Tawmaw is
573 and of coolies 620, making a gross revenue of Rs.3,508-8-0, or,
for the whole season, of over Rs.4,500. In order to explain the difference
between his figures and the Mawok's
he says that the latter is swindled by his clerk and followers, by
whom the tolls are collected. This I fancy is true, but, on the other
hand, Ko Yin Det and the traders from whom he got his information,
are anxious to secure a reduction of the tolls, and it is to their
interest to make out as big a bill as possible. Perhaps the mean between
the two figures may be nearer the truth than the figures obtained
from the Mawok's books. This would
make the total revenue Rs.3,587-8-0 divided (in round figures) as
follows:-
800 Colies... ... 1,200 Rs.
531 Mules... ... 2,390 Rs.
Total:
... 3,950 Rs.
The Tawmak Mawok maintains
a staff of six men during the working months, and of two men in
the rains, to police the mines and collect tolls; and he says that
the import tolls suffice for the up-keep of this staff. I estimate
that these men cost him from Rs.700 to Rs.800 a year. It will be
seen, therefore, that the Shan Mawok
of Tawmaw makes quite a good thing out of his appointment, and that
it is possible to reduce the tolls so that they may approximate
somewhat to the rates sanctioned by Government for the Hweka mines,
though I am afraid that it will be impossible to reduce them to
the same level because there the Duwa
lives at the mines and is his own Mawok,
while here it will be difficult to compel Kansi's successor to live
at Tawmaw.
"Management of the Mines.
- The mines are managed by Kansi's agents, who are called Mawoks.
There are two Mawoks at Tawmaw,
a Kachin and a Shan, the latter of whom collects all the export
and import dues, while Kansi La's nephew, La Saing, takes the revenue
derived from the gambling-dens. There is also a Mawok
at Mamon, who receives and keeps all the money collected there,
except the gambling-fees which are sent to Kansi La. The Mawok
of Mamon, Maung Nyi, is said to be a wealthy man. Kansi La never
went to Mamon. Each of the Shan Mawoks
maintains at his own expense a staff of five or six peons to help
him to keep order at the mines and to collect tolls.
"The mines were visited by Mr. Twomey, the Commissioner of the
Mandalay Division, in April 1907, and on his recommendation the
Local Government issued the following rules for the levying of tolls
and dues by the headman of the Jade Mines Tract:-
(a) Manhumanta at both Tawmaw
and Mamon to be levied at 10 per cent. ad
valorem on all stones sold at, or exported unsold from, the
mines. The unsold stones to be valued by assessors and, if the owner
of a stone objects to the price so assessed, the Duwa
to take over the stone at the price fixed, or else reduce the valuation.
(b) No manhumanta to be levied
on stones valued at less than Rs.100.
(c) No import tolls of any kind to be levied.
(d) Export tolls or Kyaukkun
to be levied at the rate of Rs.3 per mule and Re.1 per coolie-load
of jadestone.
(e) The rates for the rafts at Mamon to remain the same as at present.
"The Hweka Jade Mines.-The
Hweka Jade Mines are situated in the hills twelve mines [miles?]
south of Mamon and as in the latter place, the jadestone is found
in boulders. Major Townsend, writing of these mines in 1903, says:-
'Kansi La has nothing whatever to do with these mines. He is, however,
connected with the Mabu-Sainglaing Marips, who own them. These mines
were of little importance until 1897-98, when the question of appointing
a headman arose. Mabu Sao Awn was appointed temporarily, pending
the coming of age of his cousin, Saing Sao Awn. The latter has been
permitted to take over the duties and emoluments this year. These
mines have increased in importance year by year and will probably
shortly rival Mamon. They are situated on the slope of a steep hill
and are cut into two deep, broad terraces. As the excavations continue
and the earth is thrown up around them, it is probable that the
mines will take the shape of deep wells as at Tawmaw. At present
the limits of the claims are marked by long canes suspended overhead.
There are now some sixty claims allotted by the headman who does
not reserve the mines for his own family and friends as Kansi does
at Tawmaw. Here, as at Tawmaw, the work is too hard for any but
Kachins. The purchasers of the jadestone are Shans from the Upper
Chindwin or from Mogaung. It is mostly taken via
Kamaing to Mogaung, though the jade licensee has now complained
that it is being smuggled direct to the railway at Taungni and Hopin,
thus avoiding payment of royalty.'
"Dues.-
(1) Manhumanta at the rate of
one-tenth of the value of stones sold, or, if not sold, of the value
fixed by assessors.
(2) Tolls of eight annas per coolie-load and Re.1 per mule-load
of jadestone removed from the mines.
The Mawok (Mabu Sao Awn) stated he realized Rs.1,000 from the above
sources in 1901-02.
(3) License to keep a gaming-house realized Rs.600 in 1901-02 and
Rs.700 in 1902-03, paid to the Mawok.
"Tribute.-In addition to the ordinary tribute, the
Mawok pays Rs.100 per annum to Government. Kachin tribute and thathameda
are assessed and collected by the Subdivisional Officer, Mogaung
(now Kamaing), in the ordinary way."
W.A. Hertz, 1912,
Burma Gazetteer: Myitkyina District.
|
Later work
From the time of Warry and Hertz onwards, a number of British and
other Europeans gave first-hand accounts of the mines. These included
Noetling (1892-1893), Bleeck (1907-1908), and Chhibber (1934). Chhibber's
study was extensive, and remains to this day the most detailed look
at the mines in print. Space does not permit its full reprinting here,
but, suffice to say, it is the classic work on the subject. The section
below contains his comments on the jadeite trade:
JADEITE TRADE
Every piece of jadeite found has to be valued and the owner has
to pay a commission of 5 per cent. to the valuation committee at
the jade mines. As a rule the valuations in the mines are very low.
If the financier elects to keep the stone (which he generally does),
he has to pay half of the value of the stone to the coolies or workmen
after paying the Mahumanta tax
of 10 per cent. to the Duwa in whose jurisdiction the stone is found,
if it is valued at Rs.100/- or more.
It is noteworthy that in sales and valuations prices are not mentioned
openly, but are indicated by a conventional system of finger pressures
under cover of a handkerchief.
The stone is then taken away to Mogaung, either by coolies or
on mules, after paying the necessary local tolls. If a boulder is
very heavy then the coolie transport from the mines to Nanyaseik
is very costly. For instance, about fifty coolies or more have to
be engaged to transport a boulder weighing about a ton; these proceed
by very short stages and in all it may cost about Rs.1,000/-. Beyond
Nanyaseik it may be taken by bullock carts to Mogaung, or it may
be sent by river on bamboo rafts from Kamaing.
The stone can only be taken out of Mogaung after paying an ad
valorem royalty of 33 per cent. to the Government Jade License.
Much dealing in jade goes on in the mines and at Mogaung amongst
Burmese, Chinese and other traders; but it is entirely speculation,
because usually the stones are not cut until after the Government
royalty has been paid on them, and therefore their real value is
merely guess-work. I may quote here from a manuscript note by Major
F.L. Roberts, formerly Deputy Commissioner, Myitkyina. "From the
time jade is won in the Jade Mines area until it leaves Mogaung
in the rough for cutting there is much that is underhand, tortuous
and complicated, and much unprofitable antagonism. In my opinion
the whole business requires cleansing, straightening and the light
of day thrown upon it."
Shipping.-Boulders of jadeite
are wrapped in gunny bags, tied with hemp rope and then shipped
from Rangoon, in a Chinese boat to Hong Kong, Canton, Shanghai,
etc. A considerable quantity of stone is smuggled across the border,
in addition to the small amount officially carried over by mules,
which return from Burma to Yunnan and China with the advent of the
rainy season.
Buyers of Jadeite.-No definite
statistics regarding the purchasers of jadeite are available. However
an aged, experienced dealer informed me that only about 25 per cent.
of the jadeite is consumed in Burma. The remaining 75 per cent.
is sent to China and Japan, and of this a small percentage eventually
finds its way to America and Europe. The Chinese believe that the
wearing of jade prevents "evil eye," disease, or in other words
acts as a charm. Jadeite jewellery finds great favour with the Chinese
and Japanese ladies.
Centres of Jadeite trade.-A
large number of the Chinese jade merchants make their purchases
at Mogaung, but a fair number of Chinese merchants come up to the
jade mines and are to be seen buying the mineral at Hpakan, Hwehka
and other mining centres. Mandalay being the centre of cutting,
commands the largest market for jade jewellery.
Varieties of Jadeite.-The local
merchants recognise a number of varieties, depending upon their
colour, translucency and texture.
(1) Mya Yay or Yay Kyauk,
translucent and a uniform grass-green in colour. This is the most
precious variety.
(2) Shwelu.-This
is the light-green jadeite with bright-green spots and streaks.
This is next to (1) in value. Both these varieties are used for
expensive jewellery such as rings, necklaces, pendants, ear-rings,
brooches, etc.
(3) Lat Yay, clouded
jadeite, is used in making bracelets, buttons, hatpins, ornaments,
drinking cups, etc.
(4) Hmaw Sit Sit,
a dark-green variety, is rather soft and brittle, and is used in
the manufacture of cheaper jewellery.
(5) Konpi, the
red or brownish variety, is only found in boulders, embedded in
red earth. This variety is not found at Tawmaw.
(6) Kyauk-atha, white translucent jadeite, is used
for bracelets, stems of pipes, plates, spoons, flower-pots, cups,
saucers, etc.
(7) Pan-tha (Pan
in Burmese means flower, and atha
means flesh, but it here denotes the translucent white jadeite).
This variety is brilliant white in colour, and translucent, but
opaque to a certain extent. This opacity is considered to be a defect
and considerably reduces the price of the find. Like marble, it
is used purely for decorative purposes, such as inlaying tables,
chairs, boxes, and furniture generally.
(8) Kyauk Amè,
the black variety. It is used for making buttons, bars for brooches,
etc. This is the variety chloromelanite and is characterised by
containing a large percentage of iron, replacing in part its aluminium.
As the name implies, it is of dark-green colour often appearing
quite black, except in thin-nest splinters, when it is seen to be
of a slightly translucent blackish-green colour.
Jade-cutting Industry
The methods employed in the cutting of jadeite and described below
are really Chinese, and artistic carving is still mostly done in
China. Surface carving and bead-making can be done in Mandalay.
Abrasives.-Two kinds of abrasives
are used in the cutting of jadeite. For big boulders coarse carborundum
is employed, while the finer grade is used in disc-cutting described
below. Crushed gem sand from Mogok is also employed in grinding
and polishing.
About 20 years ago a basket of the gem sand from Mogok (sand weighing
about 200lb.) could be bought for a rupee (one shilling and six
pence); but at present the price varies from Rs.7/- to 15/- depending
upon the usual question of supply and demand. Before the sand is
crushed into grinding powder, the gems of better quality are picked
out to be used as jewels in watches. Most are exported to Europe,
but some are employed locally in the manufacture of cheap jewellery.
Local Preparation of Abrasives.-The
pounding and pulverising of the sand is effected by a simple contrivance.
A heavy weight is tied by means of a string strung to a bow fastened
on to the ceiling of the house. Generally this task is entrusted
to girls, who are paid according to the weight of sand they crush.
These wages vary in direct proportion to the degree of fineness
required.
The powder thus prepared is used in cutting and grinding; but
it is largely made into flat slabs by mixing it with a kind of gum
imported from China. These abrasive slabs are mounted on flat wooden
rectangular plates, there being 15 or 16 kinds of these tablets
depending upon the grade of the powder used.
The first stage in the cutting of jadeite is the sawing of the
boulders with big, heavy bamboo bows. The length of the saw is variable
and is about two feet high at the centre. The cutting is done with
steel wire; generally two of three wires are plied together. The
boulder rests on a wooden frame and the saw is worked by two men
sitting at either end. On one side there is a small basin containing
coarse carborundum powder and water, and during cutting this moist
paste is continuously poured on to the boulder by means of a long
rod either by one of the workmen or by a small apprentice boy.
Disc-cutting.-Smaller pieces
of jade are cut by means of a sharp-edged disc about 14 inches in
diameter and made of bronze. This is fitted on to a wooden axle
worked by means of a leather strap tied on to two wooden legs operated
by the cutter. Below the disc is kept a basin containing fine carborundum
and water which are constantly replenished on to the jadeite piece
which is being cut. The disc rotates at a high speed and its sharp
edge armed with carborundum powder effects the cutting. The disc
is re-sharpened by means of a small brick made of gem sand. Sometimes
before a boulder of jade is sold, if it is promising, certain portions
are polished to expose clearly to view the more valuable parts of
the stone. Generally a small rectangular strip is ground and polished.
This grinding is done by means of an emery disc, and then the exposed
portions are polished with fine emery discs. The machinery employed
in this case is the same as is used for disc-cutting, but the cutting
disc is replaced by thick emery discs.
Shaping and Polishing.-The third
stage consists in mounting the small pieces of jade on to bamboo
sticks by means of sealing wax. By skilful grinding on the abrasive
tablets of different grades the desired shape is imparted to rough
pieces. In this way buttons, bars for brooches, small pieces for
making bracelets, and beads for necklaces are made. The selection
of colour and matching of beads is entrusted to girls. The cut articles
are polished on slabs of very fine-textured stone, brass, leather,
etc.
Final Polishing.-The final polish
to the jadeite jewellery is given by rubbing the articles on a dry
bamboo with water. Finally the finished article is boiled for about
15 minutes in a solution made up as follows:
| Soda (Sapyagyan) |
- |
1 part |
| Lime |
- |
1 part |
| Water |
- |
10 parts |
The above solution is boiled for fifteen minutes and then cooled
and decanted. When the stone has undergone this treatment, it is
cleaned with cloth and is ready for sale.
Boring of holes.-The boring
of holes in necklace beads, buttons, cuff-links, etc., is a speciality
and is generally done by skilled artisans. The bead or any article
in which a hole is to be bored is fixed in a heavy wooden stage
or on to a block of wood by means of sealing wax and the hole is
bored by means of an Archimedean drill, the steel needle of which
is tipped with a high class Brazilian diamond point. The drill is
worked by means of a leather bow. On a small scale a sharp-pointed
steel rod and carborundum powder serve the above purpose.
Making of Bangles.-The making
of Jade bangles, like carving, is a speciality which involves considerable
skill and risk and it is mostly done in China. However, a little
is done in Mandalay as well.
The making of a jade bangle simply consists in first scooping
out a cylinder of jade. This is done by means of a steel cylinder
and carborundum. The same process is repeated so that a small hollow
cylinder, which represents a crude bangle, is obtained. Then the
edges are ground and the bangle is polished. This is a risky operation
and a bangle may give way in the final stages on account of an undetected
flaw in the stone.
Carving.-The utmost care has
to be exercised in carving jade. The Chinese workmen, having determined
from the natural shape of the block, and from its visible and probable
flaws, into what object he will carve it, fixes it on a lathe and
gives it the general outline. The carving machine is a kind of lathe
almost identical with the one used for disc-cutting. In this case,
however, the small steel discs vary from the size of a rupee to
that of a pice. Various types of discs are employed for coarse and
fine carving, using very fine carborundum powder for this purpose.
Work is started with the biggest disc and the artisan gradually
changes on to the finer ones. The interior is then hollowed out
first by drilling, with diamond-pointed needles, innumerable little
holes all over the surface which is to be broken away. When this
is completely honeycombed the partitions are broken down by tapping
sharply with a hammer. Too hard a tap may shatter the half-finished
object along some hidden flaw. The final polish to the carved article
is given by a leather disc. This work, even in Mandalay, is almost
entirely done by skilled Chinamen whose wages vary from Rs.3H/-
to Rs.10/- depending on the amount of work done.
It is recognised that the harder the stone the more difficult
the cutting, and the more brilliant the polish it is capable of
acquiring. So great is the difficulty of carving jade than an elaborate
piece may represent a lifetime's labour. In Kienlung's ateliers
in the Summer Palace at Peking the workmen succeeded one another
without interruption day and night. Even then many years were occupied
in completing a single piece.
Places where cutting is done in Burma.-The bulk of the cutting
is done in Mandalay, but some is done in Mogaung and a little, almost
negligible amount, in the jade mines, e.g. at Hpakan, Hwehka, etc.
Places where cutting is done in China.-It appears that jade cutting
and carving is a very extensive industry in China, the most important
centres being Canton, Shanghai and Peking, though some cutting is
done in Hong Kong also. A big cutting industry is centred at Teng
Yueh in Yunnan; so much so that every street in Teng Yueh has its
lapidary's shop and lathe.
H.L. Chhibber, 1934
Mineral Resources of Burma
|
Jade goes to war
Up until World WarII, the region remained a backwater, and few Europeans
ventured to the mines and wrote about them. This all changed with
the Japanese invasion. The following is an interesting jade war story
from a Chinese-American working on General Stillwell's staff: |
Jade!
Burma used to provide the women of this world with some of its most
precious stones. The ruby mines of Burma near Mandalay were world
famous, and you can bet that the British didn't want the American
GIs or the Chinese Pings anywhere near them. When the boundaries were
drawn between General Slim's XIV British Army and General Stilwell's
combat forces of the NCAC and the Chinese Army in India, Admiral Mountbatten
made certain that all the rubies were in Slim's area!
Jade, on the other hand, was to be found in north Burma in large
quantities. The area adjacent to the trace of the Stillwell Road
and the upper reaches of the Hukawng Valley from the India-Burma
border along the Wantuk Bum down to the Ahawk Hka had a number of
active mines still operating. Chinese troops of the 22nd and 38th
divisions were not long in discovering this fact. Nor did it take
them long to find out that local mine superintendents were not loath
to part with their precious wares in return for promises of protection
for themselves, their workers, and their property. The owners of
the mines fled when the Japanese came in, so the mine supervisors
figured they were in charge. It didn't take long either for some
of our more enterprising American officers serving as advisors (liaison)
with Chinese units to see the possibilities for making a quick fortune.
An officer came into my tent at Shaduzup one afternoon in late
May 1944. He looked around to make certain we were alone. "Charlie,"
he said in almost a stage whisper, "I've got something to show you."
He was carrying an olive-drab rubberized ration bag about the size
of a small grocery sack. He untied the string, turned it upside
down, and onto my desk fell chunks of what appeared to be rough
gray stones. There were about ten of them ranging in size from a
golf ball to a tennis ball and about fifty others, rough cut but
in a myriad of colors-green, oxblood, black, and red-ranging in
size from a large marble to a Ping-Pong ball. "Know what these are?"
asked the officer. I admitted that I did not. Taking a GI trench
knife from his belt, he proceeded to gouge into one of the rough
gray stones. As the outer crust peeled away the stone turned a beautiful
dark green. "Jade, Charlie," he said. "All of these are jade, the
reds, the blacks, all of 'em." He had convinced one of the mine
supervisors that he controlled the Chinese troops in the area and
could assure full protection to the supervisor, his mine, and his
workers. The officer seemed proud of what he had done although he
knew that I knew that he couldn't actually control any of the Chinese
and that he couldn't very well protect anyone either.
"You're staff, Charlie," he said. "You've got to have a way to
get this back to the states. What'll you give me for the lot." I
didn't want to get involved in this nefarious business, but neither
did I wish to offend the officer or make him my enemy. I had priced,
polished and finished jade in Ledo and in New Delhi. Even a rough
calculation by weight told me that this sackful must be worth at
least $10,000. "I'd sure like to help you," I said. "How about $1,000?"
"Come on, Charlie," he answered. "It's got to be worth at least
$5,000." I explained that even if I agreed with him, which I did
not, I didn't have that much money on hand. In fact, I only had
$800 and would have to borrow the rest.
The officer shrugged his shoulders, put his rocks back in the
sack, and left. I never did learn what he did with the jade, but
if he eventually got it back to the states and hung onto it, it
would be worth about $500,000 today. I guess I just wasn't cut out
for a life of crime-any kind of crime. If I had been I could have
been an opium king or a jade smuggler. Instead, I'm a retired army
officer. As it was, when I left Burma and the CBI for the last time,
I took with me a single piece of jade purchased in New Delhi for
300 rupees ($100.00).
My wife still has it. Won-Loy Chan, 1986, Burma:
The Untold Story
|
| After the war, Martin Ehrman (Smith & Smith,
1994), Meen (1962) and Gübelin (1964-1978) visited the mines and wrote
about them. Their reports are excellent, and provide much local color,
but since they are contained in journals which are commonly available,
I will not reproduce them here.
In 1962, the Ne Win-led military coup slammed the door on this
part of the globe. Only recently has it reopened. The present author
has undertaken two visits to the mines over the past year (Hughes,
1996-1997). Amazingly, little has changed from that reported by
these early visitors. Jade continues to be mined and worked by extremely
primitive methods, with the only sop to the modern age being electricity,
motorized vehicles, backhoes and dynamite. Some things never change.
Bibliography
The following is a list of the most important eye-witness (or near
eye-witness) accounts of Burma's jade mines in the Roman alphabet.
Many of these are referred to, or quoted in the above text. References
followed by RWHL indicate that I have originals or copies in my
personal library. Those followed by an asterisk are of particular
quality.
- Adamson, C.H.E. (1889) A Short Account of the Expedition to
the Jade Mines. Newcastle-upon-Tyne, J.þBell & Co., not seen.
- Bleeck, A.W.G. (1907) Die jadeitlagerstätten in Upper Burma.
Zeitschrift für Praktische Geologie, Vol.15, November, pp.341-365,
pls.4-5, figs.95-100; not seen.
- Bleeck, A.W.G. (1908) Jadeite in the Kachin Hills, Upper Burma.
Records, Geological Survey of India, Vol.36, Pt.4, pp.254-285,
pls.þ35-38, 3þfigs., reprinted in Bulletin of the Friends of Jade,
Vol.9, Jan.1996, pp.29-52; RWHL*.
- Chan, W.-L. (1986) Burma: The Untold Story. Novato, CA, Presidio,
138þpp.; RWHL.
- Chhibber, H.L. (1934) The Mineral Resources of Burma. London,
Macmillan, 320þpp; RWHL*.
- Crosthwaite, C.E. (1912) The Pacification of Burma. London,
Frank Cass & Co., Reprinted 1968 by Frank Cass & Co., 355þpp.;
RWHL*.
- Griffiths, W. (1847) Journals of Travels in Assam, Burma, Bootan,
Afghanistan, and the Neighbouring Countries. Calcutta, 529þpp.;
not seen.
- Gübelin, E.J. (1964-65) Maw-sit-sit: A new decorative gemstone
from Burma. Gems & Gemology, Vol. 11, No. 8, Winter, pp. 227-238,
255, color plate; RWHL*.
- Gübelin, E.J. (1965a) Jadealbit: Ein neuer Schmuckstein aus
Burma. Zeitschrift der Deutschen Gesellschaft für Edelsteinkunde,
No. 51, pp.þ4-22; not seen.
- Gübelin, E.J. (1965b) Maw-sit-sit proves to be jade-albite.
Journal of Gemmology, Vol. 9, No. 11, July, pp. 372-379; RWHL.
Gübelin, E.J. (1965c) Maw-sit-sit-A new decorative gemstone from
Burma. Journal of Gemmology, Vol. 9, No. 10, April, pp. 329-344;
RWHL*. Gübelin, E.J. (1978a) Jadeit: Der grüne Schatz aus Burma.
Lapis, Vol.þ3, No.þ2, pp.þ17-28; RWHL*.
- Gübelin, E.J. (1978b) Maw-sit-sit. Lapis, Vol. 3, No. 10, pp.
24-28; RWHL*.
- Hannay, S.F., Capt. (1837) [Note on jadeite in Burma]. Journal
of the Asiatic Society of Bengal, Vol.þ6, p.þ265; not seen.
- Hannay, S.F., Capt. (1857) Notes on the productive capacities
of the Shan countries, north and east of Ava, their arts and manufactures;
with a short account of the town of Bamo, as seen in January,
1836, and its trade with China and the lower Irrawaddy. Selections
from the Records of the Bengal Government, Calcutta, 1853-1900,
Vol.þ25, see p.þ11; not seen.
- Hertz, W.A. (1912) Burma Gazetteer: Myitkyina District. Rangoon,
Superintendent, Govt. Printing and Staty., Volume A, reprinted
1960, Rangoon, 193þpp., map; RWHL*.
- Hughes, R.W. (1997) Tracing the green line. Discovery, Vol.þ25,
No.þ2, February, pp.þ69-73; RWHL.
- Hughes, R.W. and Galibert, O. (1997) The green line to Hpakan.
Bangkok Post, Bangkok, Aprilþ6, 1997, Outlook: ppþ4-5; RWHL*.
- Hughes, R.W., Galibert, O., Smith, M. & Thet Oo (1996-97) Tracing
the green line: A journey to Myanmar's jade mines. Jewelers' Circular-Keystone,
Vol.þ167, No.þ11, November, pp.þ60-65; Vol.þ168, No.þ1, January,
pp.þ160-166, RWHL*.
- Keller, P.C. (1990) Gemstones and their Origins. New York, Van
Nostrand Reinhold, 144pp.; RWHL*.
- Lintner, B. (1989) Burma's jade trail. Gemological Digest, Vol.2,
No.4, pp.24-31; RWHL*.
- Meen, M.A. (1962) Gem hunting in Burma. Lapidary Journal, Vol.
16, No. 7, Oct.,þpp. 636-653 (Mogok); No.8, Nov.,þpp. 746-757
(Mogok); No. 9, Dec.,þpp.816-835 (jade); RWHL*.
- Noetling, F. (1892) Preliminary report on the economic resources
of the amber and jade mines area in Upper Burma. Records, Geological
Survey of India, Vol.25, Pt.3, pp.123-170; not seen.
- Noetling, F. (1893) Note on the occurrence of jadeite in Upper
Burma. Records, Geological Survey of India, Vol.þ26, Pt.þ1, pp.þ26-30,
pl.þ1, reprinted in Bulletin of the Friends of Jade, Vol.þ9, Jan.þ1996,
pp.þ23-28; not seen.
- Noetling, F. (1896) Über das Vorkommen von Jadeït in Ober Birma.
Neues Jahrbuch für Mineralogie, Vol.þ1, pp.þ1-17; not seen.
- Orta, G., da (1913) Colloquies on the Simples & Drugs of India.
Trans. by Sir Clements Markham, London, Henry Sotheran, English
trans. of Orta's Coloquios dos Simples e Drogas he Causas Medicinais
de India of 1563, 508þpp. (see pp. 174, 353-361); RWHL.
- Scott, J.G. and Hardiman, J.P. (1900-1901) Gazetteer of Upper
Burma and the Shan States. Rangoon, Government Printing, Burma,
5Vols., Vol.2, Part 1, Section 7, Geology and economic mineralogy;
Vol. 2, Part 2, Jade Mines, 560þpp.; RWHL.
- Smith, B. and Smith, C. (1994) Martin Leo Ehrmann (1904-1972).
Mineralogical Record, Vol.25, No.5, Sept.-Oct., pp.347-370; RWHL.
Soe-Win (1965) The jade mines of northern Burma. Working Peoples'
Daily, Rangoon, Sept.þ5, 12, 19 & 26, not seen.
- Soe-Win, U. (1968) The application of geology to the mining
of jade. Union of Burma Journal of Science and Technology, Vol.þ1,
pp.þ445-456; RWHL*.
- Yule, H. and Burnell, A.C. (1903) Hobson-Jobson. London, Routledge
& Kegan Paul, 1st ed., 1886; 2nd ed. 1903 by William Crooke, reprinted
1995, AES, New Delhi, 1021þpp. (see viss, p.967); RWHL.
|
|
|