I want to make my own engagement ring but I have no real desire
to have a Diamond (TM). I do however need a colourless stone that
is very very pretty. I have looked at some Moissonite stones and
they seemed quite nice to my eye. I looked up diamond simulants on
the web and I was deluged with Russian Brilliants,
Asha stones, Russian Ice, diamond gels, Yikes!
Not to put too fine a point on the matter, if you don’t want a
diamond, then why do you want one that will pretend to be a diamond?
Seems to me that’s a poor symbol for love, marriage, and all that.
Stimulants seem fine to me when used only for decorative purposes,
where there’s no symbolic reason for the gem. But and engagement
diamond is more than just a rock sold by a mega monopoly. It’s gained
considerable symbolic value. However, it should also be strongly
pointed out that the whole deal about using diamonds as engagement
ring stones, and in fact even the degree to which engagement rings
themselves are now somehow mandatory, is pretty much the result of
amazingly successful and long duration marketing by that same
monopoly. A considerably longer tradition of use exists for stones
other than diamond, and many are exceedingly beautiful in their own
right, as what they are, rather than what they pretend to be, and
many of these offer value based on real rarity rather than an image of
rarity that does not actually exist to the degree the public believes
(just how rare can a gem type be when it’s bought and sold as
virtually a commodity item, and every jeweler on the planet has
hundreds or thousands of them. I’d suggest, if you don’t wish a
natural diamond (bravo, I agree), the look at some of the more
durable natural stones, such as the corundum family (sapphire and
ruby) or chrysoberyl (catseye, not the quartz tigereye, but real
chrysoberyl catseye, as well as the exceedingly wonderful and rare
beauty of really fine alexandrites. These are just starting
suggestions. There are many more which can make wonderful and
unique wedding jewelry that does not look just like that bought by
every other Tom Dick or Harry on the planet…
If you’re set, however, on a diamond stimulant or other such
colorless white stone, then among the stimulants, I’d suggest
Moissonite. It is somewhat harder and tougher than the other
stimulants out there, with an appearance that, at a distance of more
than a foot or so, is very close to diamond, though it tends to show
a somewhat darker, slightly gray or even faintly green color (not
usually seen unless compared side by side with something whiter, or
by someone with some experience). But it’s costly. Cubic Zirconia,
by contrast, is dirt cheap, and can even look a tad better when new,
clean, not scratched up, etc. With that, one has the reasonable
option with some settings of using the cheap C.Z., understanding that
you can replace the darn thing with a new one every few years for
many years before you’ll have equaled the price of that moissonite
or more, a diamond. C.Z. varies in quality from vendor to vendor,
mostly in terms of cutting precision, which makes a big difference in
how closely it resembles diamond. I’d suggest the Swarovski brand,
as I’ve found their cutting to be consistently high quality. And you
can get it easy from Rio Grande if you don’t have another good
source, at close to true wholesale prices. Buy a dozen and they’re
cheaper yet, and then you’ve got your replacement stock all lined up
for down the line.
And if your reason for not wanting a diamond is the common use of it
all, remember that there are some types of diamond that are a bit
more unusual and unique, and perhaps worth considering. Natural or
irradiated colored diamonds give you all the symbolic, even if by
virtue of marketing, of white diamonds, yet they have pretty colors
that makes them quite different from the run of the mill. Natural
colors, especially in the light yellows, light browns (the so called
champagne colors) may be very affordable compared to white stones,
and with more intense yellows, very beautiful and unique, though the
price tends to rise rapidly again when the colors get intense. You
can even, in smaller sizes, get color enhanced stones in a pretty
purplish pink tone from Australia. Pricey, but very pretty. Even
pricier are natural pinks, or light blues, greens, etc. these latter
are also available in irradiated /induced color diamonds that can be
quite reasonable in price. The color is permanent, and can be very
pretty.
And if you wish the ultimate synthetic replacement for a natural
diamond, well, increasingly coming on the market these days are true
synthetic diamonds. To date, the ones I’ve seen have been bright
yellow/amber color, not white, but they’re quite pretty, and offer
the advantage of not generally being marketed through the debeers
chain of supply, so you need not worry about issues like “blood
diamonds” or the like. Colorless ones are likely to ether be here
soon, or like as not, some other Orchidian will remind me that
they’re already here and commercially available (I know they’ve been
made, but don’t know if they’re yet commercially available).
And finally, if your whole reason for avoiding natural white
diamonds is the avoid the political, economic, or environmental
issues associated with the diamond trade, then buy Canadian diamonds.
Their big marketing point is precisely that they are free from the
negative connotations associated with the rest of the world wide
diamond trade.
Just my two cents.
Peter Rowe